Repriced by Somebody Else's Quarter

AT&T beat estimates and raised its outlook. It fell 6.45% anyway, on a rival's results.

The Close

The S&P 500 rose 44.60 points, or 0.6%, to 7,757.17 — a third straight gain. The Nasdaq Composite led with 1.1%, the Dow added 0.7% to 52,856.09, and the Russell 2000 managed 0.3%.

Underneath the indexes, the day belonged to one earnings report and the damage it did somewhere else entirely. SpaceX closed up 7.79%. AT&T, which also reported and also beat, closed down 6.45%. Verizon and T-Mobile fell as well, and neither of them reported anything at all.

One Big Thing

Start with AT&T's actual quarter. Adjusted earnings of 65 cents a share against the 60 cents expected, up from 54 cents a year ago. Revenue up 5.3% to $32.3 billion. A record 769,000 new internet customers, 442,000 of them on fiber. Five billion dollars of free cash flow. And management raised its full-year profit forecast to around $2.40 a share, from a range topping out at $2.35.

Now SpaceX, reporting the same day. Revenue of $14.6 billion, up 161% from a year ago. Net income of $4.4 billion, against a loss of roughly $1.1 billion in the same quarter last year. And confirmation on the call of what it intends to do with that money: become a serious American mobile carrier, using the nationwide block of low-band spectrum it agreed on 9 October to buy from Grain Management, subject to regulatory approval.

Investors already knew SpaceX wanted to be a phone company. On Wednesday they learned it can afford to be one.

That is the whole mechanism. The spectrum deal was twelve days old and the telecom stocks had already fallen once on it. What was new was the balance sheet behind the ambition. AT&T's chief executive, John Stankey, pushed back on the call — "I wouldn't over-rotate on what I would call one carrier of low-band spectrum," he said, noting AT&T runs six to eight carriers of it in a typical city. A fair point, calmly made. The market disagreed with him to the tune of about $8 billion.

The Chart That Explains It

Only two of these five companies reported anything on Wednesday. Verizon and T-Mobile said nothing and fell anyway, repriced on a threat that has not yet taken a single customer from either of them. That is what a competitive scare looks like before any competing happens.

The Deeper Read

I should be fair to the people who sold. AT&T's quarter had soft patches of its own. It signed up 379,000 new phone customers, down from 432,000 the quarter before, and the share of customers leaving each month rose to 0.92% from 0.86%. Management also flagged heavier marketing costs ahead. This was not purely a story about someone else.

But the bulk of it was, and that is worth sitting with. Nothing about satellite phone service changed on Wednesday in any physical sense. The spectrum purchase still needs regulatory approval. Satellites remain poor at reaching you inside a building, which is where most calls happen — Stankey's actual argument, and not an unreasonable one. No subscriber has switched to anything.

What moved was an estimate of how likely something is, years out. Markets do this to incumbents constantly, and the record is genuinely mixed: sometimes the early sellers look prescient a decade later, and sometimes the disruption arrives half the size and twice as slowly as the share price assumed. Both outcomes get written up afterwards as though they were obvious at the time.

What This Means For You

Here is a question worth asking every time you read that a company fell 6%: did the news come from inside the company or outside it? A fall on a company's own numbers tells you something about the business. A fall on a competitor's numbers tells you the market has adjusted a probability — and probabilities get adjusted back.

The second thing is more personal. If you hold a broad American index fund, you owned every company in that chart on Wednesday. The rocket business and the three phone businesses. You were not required to guess which one wins, because you were already on both sides.

That is the honest case for owning the whole market: not that it earns the most, but that it spares you from refereeing a contest whose rules nobody has written yet. Worth remembering if you hold telecom shares directly for the dividend, as many retired investors do. That income now carries a view about satellites, whether you meant to take one or not.

— Anthony

* Miso Robotics is offering securities through the use of an Offering Statement that has been qualified by the Securities and Exchange Commission under Tier II of Regulation A. A copy of the Final Offering Circular that forms a part of the Offering Statement may be obtained from: invest.misorobotics.com/